Shivani logo

Usability Framework: Car

Evaluating the electric vehicle experience

Conceptual illustration of an electric vehicle dashboard with navigation and climate controls
Conceptual illustration, not a tested interface.

Overview

About the project

Role
UX Researcher
Type
Academic project
Team
Indiana University
Year
2023

Case study

About the project

Overview

About the project

Our team developed a usability framework to evaluate electric vehicle interfaces, from navigation and climate controls to everyday dashboard interactions.

The project began with an interface redesign question. Research shifted our focus toward a repeatable way for designers, researchers and engineers to identify usability problems at the task level.

Project direction in the report, p. 10

48

survey respondents

Report, p. 6

5

driver interviews

Report, p. 6

6

usability indicators

Report, p. 6

Case study

Problem

Touchscreen menus, unfamiliar controls and buried settings can distract drivers. The project asks how to evaluate individual actions in context, rather than relying on interface preference alone. Research findings, pp. 10–11.

Case study

Research

Process

What we did

Secondary research

Reviewed connectivity, safety, human-machine interaction, cognitive perception and EV-specific needs.

Driver survey

Collected 48 responses over one month, using rating scales and open-ended questions about car interfaces and EV concerns.

User interviews

Interviewed five drivers: three EV users and two non-EV users. Dashboard photos helped ground the conversations in their own cars.

Framework development

Used thematic analysis to identify six usability indicators and create a two-phase task evaluation method.

Research methods, pp. 5–7

Finding

Preference is not the whole experience

The report states that 53% of survey respondents preferred touchscreens. In interviews, frequent drivers described touchscreens as distracting and suggested combining them with physical buttons.

This contrast informed a task-specific approach: evaluate how a control works in context, not just which interaction style people say they prefer.

Survey and interview findings, pp. 10–11

Case study

Persona: user needs and requirements

People

Different drivers, different needs

Illustrative personas from the project summary, not individual research participants.

Ted Mosby

Architect

Frustrations: Too many touchscreen menus and unfamiliar icons.

Needs: Clear visual cues, onboarding support and fewer distractions.

Robin

Journalist

Frustrations: Buried settings, missing shortcuts and slow responses.

Needs: Faster navigation, customizable controls and device integration.

Barney Stinson

Businessman

Frustrations: Small text, unclear voice prompts and hard-to-find basic controls.

Needs: Larger touch targets, voice guidance and simpler interactions.

Case study

Solution

Framework

Six lenses for every task

01

Self-identification

Can drivers recognize a control and understand what it does?

02

Accessibility

Are controls easy to see, reach and use?

03

Feedback

Does the system clearly confirm actions and show its status?

04

Consistency

Do labels, icons and controls behave predictably?

05

Hierarchy

Are important information and frequent actions easy to find?

06

Task completion

Can drivers finish a task without unnecessary steps or errors?

01. Break down the task

Define a goal, identify sub-goals and split them into individual actions. For navigation: locate the control, enter a destination and start the route.

02. Evaluate each action

Score each action against the six indicators on a 1–5 scale, from failed to excellent. Record the reason for each score and opportunities for improvement.

Indicators and evaluation method, pp. 7–10

Case study

Next steps

Outcome

A framework, not a proven redesign

The deliverable was a task-based evaluation framework with a scoring table and a navigation example. It was not a shipped vehicle interface or evidence of reduced driver errors.

Manual scoring remains a limitation. Further work could compare first-time and frequent drivers and adapt the framework to different vehicles.

Limitations and future scope, p. 12

Report

Read the full report

A Novel Usability Evaluation Framework for Electric Vehicles. The 13-page academic report includes the research, six indicators, task scoring example and references.

Open the full report (PDF)